|
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
Telephone based access to Internet |
|||||||||
|
Xue Wu (wu@cs.umd.edu) Department of Computer Science University of Maryland College Park, MD 20742 USA April 2001 |
|||||||||
| Introduction | |||||||||
The rapid growth of Web services has led to a situation where companies and individuals rely more and more on material that is available on the Internet and intranets. Internet access is no longer limited to personal computers and powerful workstations in the office, but is reaching into the home, as well as on the road. A new class of electronics devices with Internet access capability called "Information Appliances" was recently born. This Internet access capability is embedded in devices such as televisions, set top boxes, home game machines, telephone-based terminals, PDAs, car navigation systems and cellular phones. As mobile phones become available for everyone as commodities, successful telephone based access to internet is becoming more and more important to improve individual productivity. However, hardware restriction, narrow bandwidth restriction and accessibility requirements are serious obstacle to the success of telephone based access to internet. The following sections analyze the requirement for telephone based access to internet, discussed existing and possible strategies for dealing with these limitations.
|
|||||||||
![]() Phone.com's solution for telephone based access to Internet |
|||||||||
|
|
|||||||||
| Recommendations | Previous | Top | Next | ||||||||
Today, as the Internet and mobile phones are becoming part of peoples daily
life, many commentators hope that the mobile Internet will be much easier to
use. However, its probably not surprising to learn that people who use cell phones
to gain access to the Web find the experience less than gratifying. The
studies[6]
conducted
in this area found that phones themselves were not difficult to use, the fault lay with
the wireless services. One reason for the poor results is that designers have carried over too many designs from the Web rather than rethinking the interface specifically for the mobile medium. Actually, according to[3], there are many characteristics made mobile phone based access to Internet different from access to Internet from PC. 1. The hardware restrictions
2. The network bandwidth
3. The Accessibility requirement Simple and easy operations of
information appliances are also very important. Unlike PC user interface, keyboard and
mouse are not suitable for mobile devices. Rather, intuitive operation like a four-button
interface (cursor forward, cursor back, select, and back buttons) is required. In this
sense, some kind of accessibility considerations, should be taken into account. All of these characteristics have to
be taken into account in designing the user agent functionality for telephone based access
to Internet. So the goal for the successful web page design is to:
|
| Guidelines | Previous | Top | Next | |
| It is not
that difficult to learn how to use telephone to access Internet and remember
those mobile phones' key functions. But, users usually encountered many lost connections and poor signposts
when using the system. So to make telephone based access to Internet more successful,
designers may consider the restrictions summarized above and the following
principles from [3] and [5]. 1. Small screen related design (1) Use short openings to sum up everything that lies beyond Displaying data on a small screen is never going to be easy. But the users made the basic principles clear. Most users, most of the time, are only online for a handful of minutes. Given this:
(2) Keep the content that appears above select and input fields to 1 or 2 lines
max. Usual mobile devices have small size of screens, and limited display capabilities, thus in many cases style sheets are not supported, or its support is limited. So, [3] gives the following principles,
(4) Avoid using tables, consider lists as alternative [3] points out that most mobile phones have small screens. If contents have table descriptions, it will be very difficult to browse them in mobile phones. In addition, though it would be possible to restructure tables in accessible way, it will be difficult for mobile devices to process complex tables due to the hardware restrictions. It would be, therefore, safe to avoid using tables whenever possible. Consider alternative structures, e.g. lists, whenever appropriate. (5) Avoid using Frames Usual mobile phones have small size of screens, and most of them
support only textual information. According to [3], frames strongly depend on screen interface, therefore,
should not be used.
(6) Avoid using images On mobile phones, it cannot be generally assumed that images are always rendered, nor can be pointed by pointing devices like mouse. Therefore, [3] pointed out that server-side image maps should not be used. On the other hand, client-side image maps can be used even if images are not rendered nor can be pointed, so authors may include client-side image maps into their contents. But in many cases images are not rendered on mobile phones. 2. Design for better Navigation
This means thinking ahead for the users. Create search paths that make sense to the users.
Here is an example from WeatherOnline.co.uk (mobile phone simulator provided by www.wap.com)
|
||
Main menu |
Submenu for regions of US |
Weather information for Baltimore |
|
(2) Use simple and familiar phrases for labeling [3][5] also provide the following design principles for Telephone based access to Internet.
3. Design to reduce the operation/waiting time
(3) Don't set a deck's expiration to a low value unless the content is highly volatile. Setting a short expiration time for non-volatile deck (e.g., static application menus) may force users to reload the deck from the server even though the deck is already in the browser cache. Applications that optimize deck caching are perceived by users to be more efficient and less costly, since they minimize connection times over the wireless network. Short deck expiration values should only be set for highly volatile content (e.g., stock quotes). 4. Design to avoid Storage Limitation (1) Avoid using Scripts, Event Handlers Usual mobile devices have limitation of memory storage, CPU power and so on, thus in many cases scripting are not supported. It should not be assumed that scripts will always be executed. Contents should be readable even if scripts are not executed. (2) Avoid using Forms Usual mobile devices support basic forms, but they don't have keyboards like desktop PCs. Content authors should keep in mind that it will be hard for users of mobile devices to input many characters. Since mobile phones don't have local file systems, some features, which depend on local file system, such as file upload, should not be used. 5. Others for convenient usage and error prevention (1) Keep soft key labels to 5 characters or less. Many devices cannot display soft key labels that exceed 5 characters, and will truncate or abbreviate any labels that are longer. (2) Use Wizards instead of forms. By using a single card for each input of information, the user can follow a natural process of entering information. User studies show that wizards make for a better user experience than forms. Finally, avoid having a separate 'submit' card. The last 'ok' of the wizard should in fact be the 'submit' option. This avoids an unnecessary additional click. (3) Use the format attribute to constrain text input fields to only allow valid character types In some applications, text entry fields can employ character format constraints. These guide users to enter the required information. For example, if users must enter a credit card number of 16 digits, the entry field can be formatted to accept 16 characters exactly. Other formatting is also possible; for example, the browser can be limited to accept only numeric entries. Use format="NNNNN" for US zip code fields. (4) Assigning access keys via "accesskey" attribute In general, it cannot be assumed that input methods which
consist
of a (full) keyboard and a pointing device such as mouse are available in mobile phones.
It is desirable that description for efficient use of input methods on mobile devices are
provided in contents. From this viewpoint, assigning access keys via "accesskey"
attribute (for A, AREA, BUTTON, INPUT, LABEL, LEGEND and TEXTAREA elements) will be
effective when it is available. This may improve accessibility of links or form related
operations.
|
||
| Websites | Previous | Top | Next |
|
According to Dr. Jakob Nielsen, a former
researcher at Bell Communications Research (Bellcore) and at Sun Microsystems: No WAP web
site is well designed. "The only wireless service that I think is fairly good is not
a WAP service: the Vindigo restaurant guide for the Palm Pilot. It makes great use of the
touch screen, to really make it pretty easy to navigate and find the restaurant reviews.
It's good because it solves a mobile problem: I'm out at a meeting or trade show or
whatever and I've got to find a good Chinese restaurant within three blocks of where I
am."
|
|
example for weather forecast |
example for m-commerce |
| Another example is yell.com.
It is a site for UK Yellow Pages and has a large section devoted to the
WAP service. (mobile phone simulator provided by www.wap.com)
|
|
The advantages of its WAP version are:
|
|
| Conclusions and future work | Previous | Top | Next | |
According to the studies conducted in the area of telephone based access to
Internet, in terms of the five attributes of usabilitylearnability, efficiency,
memorability, errors, and satisfactionmobile phones did not perform very well.
WAP-enabled phones are not that difficult to learn to use. The proper design strategies
are the keys to improve the mobile phone service quantity. Site designers should not simply copy
the content, they should better take the restrictions of mobile phones into account,
redesign the content for small screen devices and select the proper mobile phone based
application to make the mobile phones quickly
provide personal and locally relevant information to a user on the move. They should also
test the results before unleashing their sites on unsuspecting users. For the researchers
who are designing the user agent, they should also consider the restrictions of mobile
phones, make the services adapt their contents and presentation according to the
user's personal and device characteristics and the context of use. Telephone
based access to Internet is still in its infant phase now, the usability of current WAP
services is severely reduced because of a misguided use of design principles from previous
media, especially principles of Web design. But all of the efforts will finally make the
mobile phones more popular to the users in the near future. |
||
| Resources | Previous | Top | Next | |
|
||